Please, look back at Kevin Cashen's video of my reading at Bookshop Santa Cruz (May 8, 2012) and my remark there about "incommensurability." It was posted here on May 22, 2012. It can also be reached directly on You Tube at this link:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y693tTrBGJg&feature=youtu.be
Then, look at the talk from the University of Washington @ Bothell's "Convergence" conference on poetics (Sept. '12), where the pictures play another role in "illustrativity." This video was also put together by Kevin Cashen (thank you). Its link is:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Echx5aBCjg
A loose set of blogbooks, each a series of considerations on poetry and poetics, working progressively past the concerns of the Language and post-Language poets and their devolution into aestheticisms. "Post-language" in its engagement with the extra-linguistic concerns of both Tibetan and Euro-American philosophies, it also simply posts language to work toward the form of a practice of anti-aesthetics as an answer to contemporary poetic and political theory. It is an exercise book.
Monday, June 3, 2013
No Object #1
What you see is what you get. Examine that and it opens again and again, like a joke. It never says what you see is what is, although "the moons are as they are" (Dogen, again). What you get is what you will see, mountain/snow for instance. First there is a mountain, then there is no mountain, then there is a song by Donovan, then there is a great jam version by The Allman Brothers, and the Dead incorporated it too. You can only get what you've actually seen, and the way words become part of that is where money comes in. And as long as money's coming in, the music gets heard. And that's basically all you can get out of the Sixties' system unless the words bang into themselves while crowding towards their object, as in the "Mountains and Waters Sutra" of Dogen. This piece was collected in what the English-speaking world calls the Treasury of the True Dharma Eye, but the French call it La Réserve visuelle des événements dans leur justesse. "There are mountains hidden in treasures," asserts the final section of this "visual reserve of events in their justice." As we try to see what we can get from this, it occurs to me that in such a dialectical "Hegelianism without reserves" (as Reb Derrida called it), incommensurability might just be just.
Sunday, April 7, 2013
No Object #0
The object here is to bring the concept of the object into view, and to object to it. Many resources will be marshaled into this project. Baudrillard is a big help, as he was for the "Follow-Up" pieces, but so are the Tibetan Buddhists who have been writing about this for many centuries. Good old cartoons, too, will be of use because they play with images of objects. Poetry seems to have gotten stuck short of the requisite play, again, and the plastic arts (incl. photography) hesitate to object to the object most of the time and get "drawn" back into objectification.
The American Zen thing of truly objective seeing and being falls short, and so does the effort to scramble and deny realities. As Jean Baudrillard's The Perfect Crime says, there is "no longer any need to confront objects with the absurdity of their functions, in a poetic unreality, as the Surrealists did" (73). Our arts have hovered over various versions of this absurdity for a century now, grasping it and rejecting it. Recent avant-garde poetry has tried to include critique of social constructions in language by going both ways: some absurdist and some as anti-absurdist as the sentences of Ron Silliman. Claims are made for the value of parataxis over hypotaxis or the twists of hyper-hypotaxis or the exposé of phrasings like those in adverts or political memes through echo or translation, but still at the still center of it all is the assumption of a reality/unreality divide and the idea of a need to confront the reality we all live with/in.
The point that Baudrillard builds beyond these attempts is that there is "[n]o longer any need for a critical consciousness to hold up the mirror of its double to the world:" that art and thinking that would expose the falsities or positionalities of the world have been undone by our world itself. "[O]ur modern world swallowed its double when it lost its shadow, and the irony of that incorporated double shines out at every moment in every fragment of our signs, of our objects, of our models"; in this post-modern world, "things move to shed an ironic light on themselves all on their own." The fresh need to present this calls for something like parody but not resolvable into a reality opposed to the laughably ironic in our world of things--not simply "meaningful" mockery. Because things "discard their meanings effortlessly," they need only to be presented in their "visibility" for us. "This is all part of their visible sequencing, which itself creates a parody effect" (73).
The 800-year-old writings of Dogen can take us to a Japanese foothold in this area of thinking too. His moon, his finger, his words, all are pointing to it. His moon (tsuki) is total (tsu) possibility (ki).
Snow
All my life false and real, right and wrong tangled.
Playing with the moon, ridiculing wind, listening to birds....
Many years wasted seeing the mountain covered with snow.
This winter I suddenly realize: snow makes a mountain.
translated by Philip Whalen with Kazuaki Tanahashi
from Moon in a Dewdrop: Writings of Zen Master Dogen,
ed. Tanahashi (North Point: SF, 1985).
The American Zen thing of truly objective seeing and being falls short, and so does the effort to scramble and deny realities. As Jean Baudrillard's The Perfect Crime says, there is "no longer any need to confront objects with the absurdity of their functions, in a poetic unreality, as the Surrealists did" (73). Our arts have hovered over various versions of this absurdity for a century now, grasping it and rejecting it. Recent avant-garde poetry has tried to include critique of social constructions in language by going both ways: some absurdist and some as anti-absurdist as the sentences of Ron Silliman. Claims are made for the value of parataxis over hypotaxis or the twists of hyper-hypotaxis or the exposé of phrasings like those in adverts or political memes through echo or translation, but still at the still center of it all is the assumption of a reality/unreality divide and the idea of a need to confront the reality we all live with/in.
The point that Baudrillard builds beyond these attempts is that there is "[n]o longer any need for a critical consciousness to hold up the mirror of its double to the world:" that art and thinking that would expose the falsities or positionalities of the world have been undone by our world itself. "[O]ur modern world swallowed its double when it lost its shadow, and the irony of that incorporated double shines out at every moment in every fragment of our signs, of our objects, of our models"; in this post-modern world, "things move to shed an ironic light on themselves all on their own." The fresh need to present this calls for something like parody but not resolvable into a reality opposed to the laughably ironic in our world of things--not simply "meaningful" mockery. Because things "discard their meanings effortlessly," they need only to be presented in their "visibility" for us. "This is all part of their visible sequencing, which itself creates a parody effect" (73).
The 800-year-old writings of Dogen can take us to a Japanese foothold in this area of thinking too. His moon, his finger, his words, all are pointing to it. His moon (tsuki) is total (tsu) possibility (ki).
Snow
All my life false and real, right and wrong tangled.
Playing with the moon, ridiculing wind, listening to birds....
Many years wasted seeing the mountain covered with snow.
This winter I suddenly realize: snow makes a mountain.
translated by Philip Whalen with Kazuaki Tanahashi
from Moon in a Dewdrop: Writings of Zen Master Dogen,
ed. Tanahashi (North Point: SF, 1985).
Saturday, January 19, 2013
"Follow-Up" #11
It is not a question of defending radical thought. Every
idea one defends is presumed guilty, and every idea that cannot defend itself
deserves to disappear. On the other hand, one must fight all charges of
irresponsibility, nihilism, or despair. Radical thought is never depressive. On
this point, there is nearly total misunderstanding. Ideological and moralistic
critique, obsessed with meaning and content, obsessed with the political
finality of discourse, never takes into account writing—the act of writing: the
poetic, ironic, allusive force of language, of the juggling with meaning. It
does not see that the resolution of meaning is to be found there—in the form
itself, the formal materiality of expression.
…
Critics,
being unhappy by nature, always choose ideas as their battleground. They do not
see that if discourse always tends to produce meaning, language and writing,
for their part, always create illusion; they are the living illusion of
meaning, the resolution of the infelicity of meaning by the felicity of
language. And this is surely the only political—or transpolitical—act that can
be accomplished by the person who writes.
Monday, December 17, 2012
"Follow-Up" #10
"The poem attempts to pay careful attention to everything it encounters; it has a finer sense of detail, of outline, of structure, of color, and also of the 'movements' and the 'suggestions.' These are, I believe, not qualities gained by an eye competing (or cooperating) with mechanical devices which continue being brought to ever higher degrees of perfection. No, it is a concentration that remains aware of all dates of history.
'Attention'--permit me at this point to quote a maxim of Malebranche which occurs in Walter Benjamin's essay on Kafka: 'Attention is the natural prayer of the soul.'
...
And what, then, would the images be?
That which is perceived and to be perceived one time, one time over and over again, and only now and only here. And the poem would then be the place where all tropes and metaphors are developed ad absurdum.
Topos study?
Certainly, but in light of that which is to be studied,: in light of u-topia.
And human beings? and all living creatures?
In this light.
Such questions! Such demands!
It is time to turn back."
--from "Meridian" by Paul Celan, adapted from Jerry Glenn's translation given in Sovereignties in Question: the Poetics of Paul Celan by Jacques Derrida (NY: Fordham UP, 2005) pp. 182-3.
'Attention'--permit me at this point to quote a maxim of Malebranche which occurs in Walter Benjamin's essay on Kafka: 'Attention is the natural prayer of the soul.'
...
And what, then, would the images be?
That which is perceived and to be perceived one time, one time over and over again, and only now and only here. And the poem would then be the place where all tropes and metaphors are developed ad absurdum.
Topos study?
Certainly, but in light of that which is to be studied,: in light of u-topia.
And human beings? and all living creatures?
In this light.
Such questions! Such demands!
It is time to turn back."
--from "Meridian" by Paul Celan, adapted from Jerry Glenn's translation given in Sovereignties in Question: the Poetics of Paul Celan by Jacques Derrida (NY: Fordham UP, 2005) pp. 182-3.
Saturday, December 8, 2012
"Follow-Up" #9
From Baudrillard’s the intelligence of evil, or the lucidity pact again:
"The peculiar role of photography is
not to illustrate the event, but to constitute an event in itself. Logic would
demand that the event, the real, occur first and that the image come after to
illustrate it. This is, unfortunately, the case most of the time.
A
different sequence demands that the event should never exactly take place, that
it should remain in a sense a stranger to itself. Something of that strangeness
doubtless survives in every event, in every object, in every individual. This
is what the image must convey. And, to do so, it must also remain in a sense a
stranger to itself; must not conceive itself as a medium; must not take itself
for an image; must remain a fiction and hence echo the unaccountable fiction of
the event; must not be caught in its own trap or let itself be imprisoned in
the image-feedback." (99)
"There is a haziness about the real.
Reality
is not in focus. The bringing into focus of the world would be ‘objective
reality,’ that is to say, an adjustment to models of representation—exactly
like the focusing of the photographic lens on the object. Fortunately, the
world never comes definitively into focus in this way. "(98-99)
"We must then strip away, always
strip away, to get back to the image itself. Stripping away brings out the
essential point: namely that the image is more important than what it speaks
of, just as language is more important than what it signifies. "(98)
Tuesday, November 13, 2012
"Follow-Up" #8
[from Giorgio Agamben’s The Coming Community. (Minneapolis: U of Minnesota P, 1993) Trans. Michael Hardt]
“When
the real world is transformed into an image and images become real, the
practical power of humans is separated from itself and presented as a world
unto itself. In the figure of this world separated and organized by the media,
in which the forms of the State and the economy are interwoven, the mercantile
economy attains the status of absolute and irresponsible sovereignty over all
social life.” (78)
“The
extreme form of this expropriation of the Common is the spectacle, that is, the
politics we live in. But this also means that in the spectacle our own
linguistic nature comes back to us inverted. This is why (precisely what is
being expropriated is the very possibility of a common good) the violence of
the spectacle is so destructive; but for the same reason the spectacle retains
something like a positive possibility that can be used against it.” (79)
“For
this very reason, ..., the era in which we live is also that in which for the first
time it is possible for humans to experience their own linguistic being—not
this or that content of language, but language itself; not this or that true
proposition, but the very fact that one speaks. Contemporary politics is this
devastating experimentum linguae that
all over the planet unhinges and empties traditions and beliefs, ideologies and
religions, identities and communities.
Only
those who succeed in carrying it to completion—without allowing what reveals
[itself] to remain veiled in the nothingness that reveals [itself], but
bringing language itself to language—will be the first citizens of a community
with neither presuppositions nor a State, where the nullifying and determining
power of what is common will be pacified. … [T]hey will enter into the paradise
of language and leave unharmed.” (82)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)